2025-12-15 19:39:00

The UK Supreme Court recently issued a significant ruling, refusing to hear the over $13 billion appeal filed by the BSV investor group. This decision upholds the lower court’s original judgment and has far-reaching implications for the legal risks faced by exchanges due to asset delistings.

The core issue revolves around the period in 2019 when major exchanges such as Binance, Kraken, ShapeShift, and Bittylicious collectively delisted BSV. In response, investors initiated a large-scale lawsuit through BSV Claims Limited, attempting to hold the exchanges legally liable. However, from the lower courts to the Supreme Court, judicial authorities unanimously determined that the investors' claims lacked sufficient legal grounds.

This ruling effectively provides important judicial protection for the autonomy of exchanges in asset management. It clearly indicates that exchanges have the independence to make decisions regarding listing and delisting assets, and investors find it difficult to overturn such business decisions unilaterally through legal channels. For the entire industry, this ruling further clarifies the boundaries of rights between exchanges and investors and may influence how similar disputes are handled in the future.

View Original

This page may contain third-party content, which is provided for information purposes only (not representations/warranties) and should not be considered as an endorsement of its views by Gate, nor as financial or professional advice. See Disclaimer for details.

8 Likes

Reward
8
10
Repost
Share

Comment

0/400

EyeOfTheTokenStorm

· 2025-12-18 08:59

From historical data, this wave of verdicts has already been reflected in the technical analysis. The $13 billion lawsuit was a complete failure—classic market pricing efficiency. The issue of exchange autonomy is actually a watershed moment. In the future, investors need to be more diligent in risk management, as relying solely on legal rights protection is basically a dead end. This is the true market separating the genuine from the false. The bottoming pattern has been confirmed without error.

View OriginalReply0

SnapshotBot

· 2025-12-17 04:56

Exchanges win, investors have to accept defeat again. This is the reality of Web3. --- Haha, that group of BSV people are really persistent. 13 billion yuan couldn't even sway the court... --- Basically, the exchange has the power of life and death; retail investors have nothing to fight with. --- This ruling has a pretty big impact on the entire crypto ecosystem. In the future, delisting assets might become more casual. --- Got it. In the end, the law still favors capital. Is it my fault? --- So all those delisted coins were a waste? The law can't even protect them... --- But on second thought, if investors had such great power, exchanges wouldn't dare do anything. That wouldn't be right either. --- Lost a lawsuit worth 13 billion? That's hilarious. This deal was a total loss. --- The boundaries of rights are now clear. Next time, don't bother with similar issues. --- After all this, the exchange is just the parent, and we are the grandchildren.

View OriginalReply0

MetaverseHobo

· 2025-12-16 09:41

Ha, BSV lost the lawsuit again? It was bound to happen earlier. I knew from the start that the lawsuit route was a dead end, and it took so long to figure that out. Now exchanges have even more reason to delist at will; investors just have to accept it. Exchanges say delete, then delete; we can only accept our bad luck. The court has already ruled, and investors are completely out of the game this time.

View OriginalReply0

AirdropHustler

· 2025-12-15 20:09

Haha, another big sucker getting taken for a ride, and $13 billion just gone? --- The autonomy of exchanges should have been clarified long ago. Investors want to win lawsuits? Dream on. --- BSV really took the cake this time. Having the appeal rejected is the biggest insult to the little guys. --- Basically, it means that the legal system in the crypto world has improved. Exchanges no longer have to be blindly sued. --- This verdict is actually good news for us. At least the rules are clearer, and we don’t have to be anxious every day. --- Wait, the case from 2019 is only now being decided? Is the court system this slow... --- Investors are so naive, thinking that buying coins can somehow restrict the exchanges? --- I think this is a hint that certain coins should have been delisted long ago, otherwise why team up and act together? --- 13 billion yuan, how many people's hard-earned money is that? Heartbreaking. --- Wow, from the lower courts to the Supreme Court, no wins. This lawsuit was doomed from the start.

View OriginalReply0

BearMarketSurvivor

· 2025-12-15 20:04

Haha, now BSV people should be heartbroken... The issue of exchanges having autonomy should have been clarified long ago. --- $13 billion lawsuit just gone like that? That's interesting. --- Basically, defending rights in the crypto world is still too difficult; exchanges are always like the parents. --- This verdict is actually quite hurtful to retail investors... Exchanges can delist whatever they want, and we have no say at all. --- The UK court has sided with the exchanges this time, but I still think there's a lot of complexity behind this. --- So next time an exchange tries to deceive us, we’ll have even fewer options... --- Is the BSV story completely over now? Feels like the topic has gone a bit off track. --- Legally, even if the exchange wins, it doesn't change everyone's opinions about certain coins. --- Once this verdict is out, investors in the crypto space who want to cause trouble will have to behave more honestly.

View OriginalReply0

NFTRegretter

· 2025-12-15 20:02

Haha, BSV investors are really out of options now; even the courts can't be bothered to pay attention. --- Exchanges arbitrarily delist coins, and investors, we just have to accept it. --- Basically, the exchange has absolute authority; us retail investors can only watch. --- Losing a $13 billion lawsuit? What were they thinking? --- This ruling is like giving the exchange a free pass; they can delist whoever they want in the future. --- It was about time; this saves everyone from hoping that the law can save the market. --- So it turns out that courts also think investors' lawsuits are ridiculous, haha. --- It seems that doing business in the crypto world relies on exchanges; investors really have little say. --- Another lesson: don’t always rely on the law to save your coins.

View OriginalReply0

DegenGambler

· 2025-12-15 20:02

Haha, BSV people lost again. Now there's really no hope. --- $13 billion just gone. Exchanges really are the boss. --- So, thinking that the crypto world can rely on legal lawsuits is really naive. Exchanges can delist whoever they want. --- But on the other hand, this isn't great for other coins either. --- I've known this outcome for a long time. BSV never had much support to begin with. --- The exchange's power is so great, us retail investors really have no way out. --- This ruling is like giving the exchange a get-out-of-jail-free card. It's a bit outrageous. --- So in the future, who dares to oppose the exchange? They simply can't win. --- Why hasn't BSV been completely wiped out yet? It's really resilient.

View OriginalReply0

BoredWatcher

· 2025-12-15 19:50

Haha, BSV is still messing around. It was about time to accept defeat. --- Exchange daddy won, investors suffered heavy losses. --- Basically, the exchange can delist whoever it wants, and even the law is on their side. --- 13 billion gone, how desperate must that be? --- Sure enough, defending rights in the crypto world is a joke. --- Just delist it if you want, since the courts are on the exchange's side anyway. --- I just want to see how long BSV can keep messing around.

View OriginalReply0

TokenVelocity

· 2025-12-15 19:42

Haha, the BSV incident has finally come to an end. Even the Supreme Court says there's no hope, investors are probably going to admit defeat. Now the exchanges are even more confident, they can delist coins at will and no one can sue. It's really ironic. So many people held BSV back then, and now they finally understand what "autonomy" really means. The court's ruling means exchanges can do whatever they want, and investors have no way to defend their rights. I do feel a bit sorry for BSV holders, but honestly, this lesson is very costly. Once this ruling is out, exchanges can delist whatever they want, and investors can only accept it. But on the other hand, this is really a reassurance for exchanges, allowing them to wash their hands of user asset risks.

View OriginalReply0

DogeBachelor

· 2025-12-15 19:40

Haha, the BSV crowd still wants to turn things around, but the court's statement directly seals the verdict. Exchanges say delist, then delist—now investors should be smarter. $13 billion down the drain, it's about time for such a ruling. Wait, is this giving the exchanges a green light... what about my coins? The law sides with the exchanges; retail investors will have to accept it. After this ruling, another wave of coins will probably be cold-processed. But honestly, whose fault is it for putting your coins on exchanges? That's the risk.

View OriginalReply0